Make Your Own Margarita Mix

Make Your Own Margarita Mix

Margaritas are one of the most popular cocktails in the world, and while any margarita can be good, making a margarita mix at home is the best way to make your margaritas even better. It is simple to do and keeps well in the fridge, so it’s a no-brainer way to have delicious margaritas at home anytime! 

Let’s dive into making your own margarita mix from scratch!

Make Your Own Margarita Mix

Benefits of Making Your Own Margarita Mix

Benefits of Making Your Own Margarita Mix
Refreshing Homemade Classic Margarita with Lime and Salt

Making a homemade margarita mix has some great benefits over the ones from the store. 

No Artificial Ingredients

For one, there are no artificial ingredients in the homemade stuff as you use whole ingredients to make the mixture. The store-bought mixes often have ingredients you can’t even pronounce, but there is none of that in a homemade version.


Additionally, the ingredients for homemade margarita mix are inexpensive, so it is a cost-effective way to make margaritas, especially if you are making a big batch. 

Customization Options

There are always more customization options for a homemade margarita mix. For instance, if you prefer it sweeter, you can make it to your liking. In the margarita mix recipes below, you’ll see that they each are a bit different, which showcases the customization options of making the mix yourself. 

Better Flavor

Finally, which we think is the best benefit, is the fact that homemade margarita mix just tastes better because you are using fresh ingredients that have nothing extra added to them that would affect the flavor. If you are looking for the best margarita flavor, a homemade margarita mix is the way to go.

Components of a Homemade Margarita Mix

Components of a Homemade Margarita Mix

Though every homemade margarita mix recipe varies slightly, some main components pop up in several of them. 

Main Ingredients

Almost every homemade margarita mix recipe includes a sweetener, lime juice, and either lemon juice or orange juice. 

Tequila and Triple Sec

From there, many people will also add triple sec or orange liqueur; however, others add tequila and triple sec when they are ready to serve. It all depends on your preference! 

Sweetener Options

When it comes to the sweetener component, there are many options. You can make a simple syrup with granulated sugar and water, or if you want to save some time, you can go with store-bought simple syrup. Other sweetener options include agave nectar, maple syrup, or honey. 

Equipment for Making Margarita Mix

Equipment for Making Margarita Mix
Photo Credit:

Many of the things you’ll need for making margaritas from scratch are likely already in your kitchen! Here is some of the equipment that would be helpful to have: 

  • An airtight container or pitcher for easy pouring and storing
  • A handheld citrus juicer makes juicing easier (you’ll be juicing a lot!)
  • A small saucepan if you are making homemade simple syrup
  • A measuring cup (unless you want really strong margaritas!)
  • Don’t forget a big spoon for stirring!

Tips and Tricks of Making The Best Margarita Mix at Home

Tips and Tricks of Making The Best Margarita Mix at Home

Making a margarita mix recipe at home is quite easy, but there are a few tips and tricks that can be helpful. 

Juicing Tips

For instance, room temperature citrus will give you a lot more juice than cold citrus. So before you try to juice the limes for your lime juice, make sure that you let them come to room temperature. 

Frozen Margaritas

Though you may not think of making a frozen margarita with the homemade mix you made at home, it is actually quite easy to do. Make up your margarita recipe without the tequila or triple sec, and then freeze it in ice cube trays. 

Once frozen, take a few cubes and place them in a blender, add your silver tequila and triple sec, then blend! If you want to make a frozen virgin margarita, all you have to do is blend the cubes without the liquor.

A Secret Ingredient

Citric acid is a secret ingredient that you can use to enhance flavor and preserve your mix for up to two weeks in an airtight container. Citric acid is naturally found in citrus fruits but is also available in a powder, usually in the seasoning aisle at the grocery store. 

Adding additional citric acid beyond the fresh juice you put in your mix adds extra oomph that will give your margarita 5-stars! However, even without the citric acid, your mix will last up to a week in the fridge. 

Best Homemade Margarita Mix Recipes

Though you can make up your own homemade margarita mix recipe, these are great margarita recipes for gathering some inspiration. 

1. Homemade Margarita Mix

By A Beautiful Mess

Homemade Margarita Mix

This homemade margarita mix by A Beautiful Mess is an easy recipe that will allow you to enjoy margaritas without all of the work. 

It simply combines water and sugar in a small saucepan and heats it on medium heat until the sugar dissolves to make the simple syrup, and then mixes it with fresh lime juice after it’s cooled.  

2. Best Homemade Margarita Mix Recipe

By Inspired by Charm

Best Homemade Margarita Mix Recipe

The Best Margarita Mix Recipe by Inspired by Charm is a simple recipe that first uses sugar and water to make a simple syrup and then combines it with lemon and lime juice. 

Depending on how many margaritas you are making, you may need to half the recipe because it makes 20 margaritas! Add a little tequila and triple sec before serving, and you have a cocktail that is a party favorite. 

3. Best Margarita Mix Recipe

By A Couple Cooks

Best Margarita Mix Recipe

The Best Margarita Mix Recipe by A Couple Cooks is a great recipe that is more sour than sweet. It uses fresh lime juice, lemon juice, and Cointreau or any other high-quality triple sec, which is what gives it a bit of sweetness. 

For a single margarita, combine 3.5 tablespoons of the homemade mix with three tablespoons of good tequila. If it is not already cold, shake with some ice in a cocktail shaker before pouring it into your salt-rimmed prepared glass.

4. Margarita Mix Recipe

By Nellie Bellie

Margarita Mix Recipe

Nellie Bellie’s Margarita Mix Recipe adds fresh mint to liven up your margaritas. Though you don’t have to include it in your own margaritas, it is a great idea for not only adding a fresh touch but also as another garnish beside a lime wedge. 

They also use fresh limes for their lime juice and either lemon or orange juice alongside a simple syrup. It is one of the recipes that makes the best margaritas because it is the perfect combination of fresh, sweet, and sour. 

5. Margarita Mix Recipe

By Wholefully

Margarita Mix Recipe

This Margarita Mix Recipe by Wholefully uses both the juice and the zest of oranges and limes to give the margarita a deeper flavor! 

It also is a more concentrated mix because the juices, zest, and sugar are all heated together without water. After making the mix, simply add tequila over ice or freeze into cubes for a frozen margarita. 


Here are the most frequently asked questions about margarita mixes and their answers. 

Is it cheaper to make your own margarita mix?

Yes, it is often cheaper to make your own margarita mix. 

What is margarita mix made of?

Store-bought mixes for margaritas are often made up of sugary, syrupy ingredients such as high fructose corn syrup, but a homemade margarita mix recipe often includes fresh lime, orange juice, simple syrup, and orange liqueur. Then all you have to do is add the tequila. 

How do you make store-bought margarita mix better?

A store-bought mix for margaritas can be made better by adding freshly squeezed lime juice or other fresh ingredients like blood oranges. 

Make Homemade Margarita Mix

If you are making margaritas, there is nothing better than using a homemade margarita mix. Though you can create your own recipe to make a margarita, if you need some inspiration, you can search recipes to find ones like the five above! 

Whether it is Cinco de Mayo or happy hour on the weekend, grab your tequila and a measuring cup and make a margarita that will be the best you’ve ever had with a homemade margarita mix.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *