The Best Bloody Mary Mix: Premade and Homemade

The Best Bloody Mary Mix: Premade and Homemade

The best Bloody Mary mix makes all the difference in one of the world’s favorite brunch-time cocktails. But which one will you enjoy the most?

The classic Bloody Mary, which was originally called the Red Snapper and was a savory cocktail brought over from Paris to New York City. It’s perfect for brunch, happy hour, and a summer treat.

Though you can make mixes from scratch, there are plenty of excellent premade mixes on the market. 

Best Premade Bloody Mary Mixes

If you are on the hunt for the perfect Bloody Mary mix, you are in luck. These are the top premade Bloody Mary mixes on the market.

Zing Zang

Zing Zang is an award-winning mix. It is known for its zesty, boldness, and spicy flavor. The mix includes seven vegetable juices plus a blend of spices that makes Zing Zang unlike any other. It is important to note that Zing Zang contains wheat, soy, and fish, so it may not be an option for individuals with allergies.

Charleston Bloody Mary Mix

Charleston Bloody Mary Mix is an all-natural option made with bold ingredients like habanero pepper mash, anchovies, and beef base. The ingredient list is transparent, and the resulting taste is slightly sweet with a tangy, umami profile.

Mr. And Mrs. T

Mr. & Mrs. T is a well-known brand in the cocktail world, so it’s no surprise that their original Bloody Mary mix is top-tier. 

They have perfected the art of simplicity using 95% ripe tomato juice, lemon, sea salt, and coarse cracked black pepper as the primary ingredients in their recipe. It has a subtle spice from the pepper, though compared to other cocktail mixes, this is perfect for getting good flavor without the punch. 

Mr. and Mrs. T also offer a spicy version that’s made with a blend of red cayenne pepper, jalapeno, and chipotle.

Tabasco Bloody Mary Mix

Hot sauce is almost always an ingredient in a great Bloody Mary mix, whether you make it yourself or buy a premade mix. 

Tabasco is a classic brand when it comes to hot sauce, so unsurprisingly, they have their own mix. It’s spicy, tangy, and a great choice.


McClure’s Bloody Mary Mixer is a thick mix as it contains fresh ingredients that are chopped. 

The base is water, vinegar, tomato paste, cucumber juice, and salt (essentially a pickle brine), but just the right amount of freshly chopped peppers, garlic, dill, and black pepper are added for a nice texture and a refreshing twist compared to many brands.

V8 Bloody Mary Mix

V8 has taken their classic vegetable juice and remixed it with the perfect blend of spices to create a classic Bloody Mary cocktail mix. 

V8 Bloody Mary Mix has three flavor blends to choose from as well, including Black Pepper, Spicy Hot, and Low Sodium, depending on what kind of Bloody Mary is your personal favorite.

Demitri’s Bloody Mary Mix

Demitiri’s takes a different approach to the Bloody Mary mix world since they provide a seasoning mix that you combine with tomato juice. 

This is perfect for those who want to control how tomato-forward their savory cocktail is. Add a few dashes or a lot, depending on your taste buds. One small bottle is designed to make 32 cocktails, it’s made with all-natural ingredients, and it is gluten-free.

Old Bay Bloody Mary Mix

Old Bay is a popular seafood seasoning with a distinctive taste. It is one of those seasonings that you either love or hate. However, if you are a fan, you’ll be glad to know that there is an Old Bay Seasoned Bloody Mary Mix. 

It’s a fun offering from George’s Beverage Company which makes its cocktail mixes by hand and always in a small batch for quality.

The Real Dill

The Real Dill is a favorite brand for pickle lovers. If you love pickles and big flavors, The Real Dill Bloody Mary Mix is a great choice. It’s spicy, full of flavor, and has a great consistency that is just slightly chunky. 

Most people who try it get hooked, so for those with high expectations, The Real Dill is a go-to.

Finest Call

Finest Call is a brand that is found behind bars at restaurants and pubs across the country. The formula features a base of tomato juice with other flavors like pure lemon juice, Worcestershire sauce, jalapeno pepper, and horseradish. 

One of the key benefits of Finest Call is the patented “bartender designed” pour spout and closure, making it mess-free and easy to pour with speed and accuracy. 

Ocean Spray Bloody Mary Mix

When you think of Ocean Spray, you likely think of cranberries, but they have a good Bloody  Mary mix. The interesting part? The mixer has cranberry juice in it! 

Don’t worry; it still has tomato juice, horseradish, and various spices, so it’s not sweet. It just adds a bit of tartness that balances everything.

Whiskey Willy’s

Whiskey Willy’s is a mix that was created by a bartender with over 18 years of experience. It is low in sugar and calories, is gluten-free, and is made from fresh local Alabama ingredients. Even if you are hesitant about some Bloody Marys, you’ll like Whiskey Willy’s. Everyone does!

Agalima Organic Low Sodium Bloody Mary Mix

Agalima Organic Authentic Mix isn’t actually marketed as a low-sodium option though it has a significantly less amount of sodium per serving than most of the top competitors, and the serving size hasn’t been cut to do it. 

This mix is made from certified organic ingredients such as Roma tomatoes, fresh lemon juice, house-made Worcestershire sauce, hot horseradish, and smoky chipotle peppers. It is truly one of those cocktail mixers that has focused on quality over quantity.

Stonewall Kitchen

If you love spicy Bloody Marys, the Stonewall Kitchen Peppadew Sriracha Bloody Mary Mixer is an excellent option. It’s gluten-free, non-GMO, and has the perfect spice level combined with fresh citrus and a good flavor.

Traeger Bloody Mary Mix

Traeger offers a concentrated punch of smoky flavor and spice from horseradish and hot pepper. It is a good mix to dilute with fresh tomato juice for a Sunday Bloody Mary, or it can even be used as a marinade. Bacon is a must-have garnish with this one. It pairs perfectly!

Filthy Bloody Mary Kit

Filthy is making one of the best mixes on the market, but they also sell a convenient Bloody Mary kit. It comes with pepper and pickle flavor stuffed olives, the cocktail mix, and some nice cocktail picks. The olives come in the oil-free Filthy olive brine, too, which just adds more flavor!

Best Bloody Mary Mix Recipes

If you would rather make your Bloody Marys from scratch, check out one of these fantastic recipes.

Spicy Bloody Mary Recipe

by Kroll’s Korner

This recipe from Kroll’s Korner uses traditional ingredients with a few twists. It combines pickle juice, tomato juice, lemon juice, Worcestershire, pepper, celery salt or celery seed, sriracha, horseradish, and of course, your favorite vodka. The key is to let it chill overnight or for several hours so the flavors can blend!

Loaded Bloody Mary Mix Recipe

by The Novice Chef

The Novice Chef has a great Loaded Bloody Mary Recipe. The mix contains all of the traditional ingredients for Bloody Marys, plus cajun seasoning and your favorite hot sauce. Then the Novice Chef gives you all kinds of lavish ideas for garnishes to make it truly loaded.

Low-Carb Bloody Marys

by Sweet As Honey

Following a low-carb diet? No problem. Bloody Marys can be made to fit a Keto or low-carb lifestyle. Simply follow this recipe here from Sweet As Honey!

Does Bloody Mary Mix Go Bad?

Bloody Mary mix can go bad, especially if it is not stored properly or it’s way past its expiration date. 

Most premade mixes have a shelf-life of 12-18 months if unopened. Once the mix has been opened, it is important to refrigerate it and consume it within one to two weeks, depending on the manufacturer’s instructions. 

You’ll know your mix has gone back if there is any change in texture, color, appearance, or odor. It is important to note that some separation is natural and does not indicate spoilage.


Which Bloody Mary mix is best?

There are several great mixes on the market, but a few of the top choices include Zing Zang, Filthy, and The Real Dill.

What does Zing Zang Bloody Mary Mix taste like?

Zing Zang tastes zesty, bold, and a bit spicy. It is strong in umami flavor with peppery notes and a hint of citrus.

What Bloody Mary mix does Disney use?

Disney uses several different mixes depending on the restaurant or location. Some of their Bloody Mary mixes are made in-house, too.

Does vodka quality matter in Bloody Mary?

Vodka quality in a Bloody Mary is a matter of debate as some mixologists say that the other ingredients smother the vodka taste anyways, so it doesn’t matter what quality you use, while others say that you should use a complimentary vodka which is usually infused vodkas to bring out and compliment the flavors.

Key Takeaways

  • There are a number of tasty Bloody Mary Mixes on the market that can be made quickly by just adding vodka.
  • The best mix depends on your taste, as there are tons of flavor remixes to switch up the drink, such as a spicy mix with hot peppers or ones with a strong pickle flavor.
  • Proper storage is key for keeping your mix fresh.
  • Add fun garnishes to pre-made mixes like celery stalk, bacon, or even shrimp!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *